Pizza restaurants

Pizza Plus

4 339 reviews 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM 863 Rutledge Pike, Blaine, TN 37709, United States

Discover this place

Pizza Plus is a local pizza restaurant located on Rutledge Pike in Blaine, Tennessee. The menu centers around classic and specialty pizzas, including options like Buffalo Chicken Pizza and bacon ranch varieties, alongside Italian-inspired dishes such as calzones and garlic cheese bread. The restaurant offers a casual and welcoming atmosphere that recalls the charm of traditional pizza eateries, featuring a modest-sized dining space that suits both families and individuals. In addition to its pizza selection, Pizza Plus provides a fresh salad bar, emphasizing garden-picked ingredients to complement the meal. Customers can expect a straightforward dining experience focused on quality and value, with generous portion sizes and reasonable prices. The combination of varied pizza styles, simple Italian fare, and a comfortable setting makes Pizza Plus a notable destination for pizza lovers in the Blaine area.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Drive-through
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza Plus before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza Plus

339 reviews

100%

40%

21%

18%

Review highlights

Based on 339 reviews

Pizza Plus in Blaine, TN, is frequently praised for its flavorful, well-prepared pizzas that strike a balance between quality and portion size at a reasonable price. Reviewers often highlight the freshness and taste of their offerings, including unique items like the berry Dutch dessert and a notable salad bar praised for its garden-fresh quality. The restaurant’s atmosphere is described as cozy and reminiscent of classic pizza establishments, complemented by friendly, attentive staff. Customers appreciate the efficient service and the availability of both à la carte options and buffet-style dining. Overall, Pizza Plus is recognized for delivering consistently satisfying meals in a welcoming environment, making it a favored spot for families and locals seeking good value and a nostalgic dining experience.

Kelly Stiles

Mar 27, 2026

Delicious picture perfect pizza tonight, and the berry Dutch needs no words. Way to start 2026 Blaine Pizza Plus!

Jen Collins

Mar 24, 2026

They always make the right pizza for me that tastes really good the bacon ranch pizza and they don't take a long time

Debbie Johnson

Mar 23, 2026

Their salad bar was the best I ever tasted. It tasted like it had just been picked out of the garden. And the kids loved their pizza. We came from Indiana.

Clinton Adkison

Jan 17, 2026

Love this place. Great lunch buffet and the staff are very nice. Reminds me of the old school pizza huts growing up but smaller in size.

Lyllyth La Fay

Jan 14, 2026

Good food. The pizza stick were delicious. Covered with cheese and came with marinara sauce. I ordered a medium pizza with 3 toppings. Will bring the leftover home and enough for a second meal. 13.99 was a good price for it. Quality vs quantity. Other places are more expensive. Second time I came here since last year. Will come back for sure (not because I live around the corner either).

Josh Posey

Jan 12, 2026

I love it! The pizza is always perfect. It's hot and fresh. The ingredients are great and you get plenty of cheese. The garlic cheese bread is amazing. The baked spaghetti is so good too. They follow strict guidelines and most places have a drive thru.

Brooke Luallen

Jan 07, 2026

If u asked me two yrs ago I would refuse to eat here, but the last yr I've been ordering again it has all been great & fresh. Good job.

Chelsea Faulkner

Dec 02, 2025

Oh my! If you are craving pizza this is where to get it! Absolutely wonderful food. We got 2 large pizzas and 16 wings, all of which were delicious! Ordering service was excellent, delivery was on time and food was hot and fresh! Delivery service was also very kind! We were impressed! The fact that you deliver to my address is a blessing in itself!! Thanks for such a great experience! Most definitely recommending to friends and family and will now be my go to pizza place!!